Planning for Progress in 2019

planning-2019-03-20-3.jpg

Progress PA activists came out in force on March 20th to help plan for the future.  Thanks to everyone who crammed into the room in the back of the Panera’s and took part in our “multi-voting” exercise.  It was encouraging to talk and laugh together again. The last time that room was that full was at our very first (indoor) gathering, when Progress PA was just beginning to form!

This time, we asked you to let us know what sparks your passion for 2019 activism.  Here are the results:

On the type of events you want to participate in, it was about evenly split between educational events, rallies, and electoral activities.  Yinz are ready to get down to work! And that’s good, because there is plenty of work to be done.

planning-2019-03-20-event-type-completed-ballot

As for topics, you showed a clear preference for targeting an elected official, plus paying attention to local and state politics.  

 

We also asked for your ideas.  There are too many to list here, but some of the topics you addressed are

  • Voter education
  • voter registration
  • Rallies
  • partnerships with other groups
  • Fair Districts & gerrymandering
  • environmental issues
  • target Turzai
  • get out the vote for local elections

And one last thing: a plea from candidate for North Hills School Board Deanna Philpott needs your help. Please knock doors for her campaign! These races can be won by just a few votes, and every voter counts.

Thanks again for Planning for Progress!

planning-2019-03-20-9planning-2019-03-20-5planning-2019-03-20-8.jpgplanning-2019-03-20-7

 

Call to Action for mid-December: the tax bill, and so much more

There are no end of topics to call our elected officials about. The tax bill is so huge and so rushed that it is hard to understand all the ways in which it will affect citizens. Here are just a few:

– Keep contacting Senators and Representatives to tell them to vote against the tax bill. It ain’t over till it’s over.

– If you want to get specific about the tax bill, here are just a few points to press:

  • Keep the medical expense deduction. Losing this deduction will harm children and the elderly.
  • Don’t tax graduate student tuition.
  • The rushed process for passing this bill is not good government.
  • Why does the bill give preference to private religious schools? Is separation of church and state important to (Elected Official)?
  • Ask if (Elected Official) intends to cut Medicare in order to address the huge deficit the tax bill will create. Will he cut Medicaid? How about Social Security?
  • Why are tax cuts for the wealthy permanent, while those for struggling families expire?
  • Does the (Senate/House) tax bill remove the loophole for carried interest for hedge fund managers? Oh, you have no idea? Why don’t you know? Was the bill too long and rushed for you to read?

– Demand that Rothfus push hard for CHIP funding. That’s the Children’s Health Insurance Program. Funding in PA is going to run out very soon. Does he care about children, or just fetuses? Rothfus has signed a letter to the Speaker of the House urging funding for CHIP, but we suspect this is just window dressing and that he will not actually get this done. Many, many children stand to lose their health coverage.

– Contact State PA House Speaker Turzai to insist that he remove Rep. Daryl Metcalfe from Committee Chair of the State Government Committee. Metcalfe’s continued hateful behavior and refusal to listen to constituents shows that he is unfit for this position. Harrisburg phone (717) 772-9943   Harrisburg Fax: (717) 772-2470

– Tell Congressman Rothfus what you think of his vote on allowing concealed carry of weapons across state lines, regardless of local state laws. Don’t ever let a Republican lecture you about states’ rights again. States’ rights prevail except for gun legislation.

– Keep up the pressure on all federal legislators on the Dreamers/DACA issue (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals).  There is no reason these valuable young contributors to our economy and society should be left in limbo, or forced to leave the country.

Contact information

US Senator Pat Toomey (R-PA)                     http://www.toomey.senate.gov/
Senator Toomey in Pittsburgh Office
310 Grant St, Suite 1440
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: (412) 803-3501
Fax: (412) 803-3504

Senator Toomey in Washington, D.C.
248 Russell Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20510
Phone: (202) 224-4254
Fax: (202) 228-0284

US Senator Bob Casey (D-PA)                        https://www.casey.senate.gov/
Senator Casey in Pittsburgh Office
310 Grant Street, Suite 2415
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: (412) 803-7370
Fax: (412) 803-7379

Senator Casey in Washington, D.C.
393 Russell Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20510
Phone: (202) 224-6324
Toll Free: (866) 802-2833
Fax: (202) 228-0604

US Representative Keith Rothfus
Rep Rothfus – District Office in Ross Township
6000 Babcock Boulevard, Suite 104, Pittsburgh, PA 15237
Phone: (412) 837-1361                     Fax: (412) 593-2022

Rep. Rothfus – Washington, D.C. Office
1205 Longworth Building, Washington, DC 20515
Phone: (202) 225-2065          Fax: (202) 225-5709

PA House Speaker        Rep. TURZAI   
District
Hon. Mike Turzai
125 Hillvue Lane, 1st Floor
McCandless, PA 15237
(412) 369-2230
Fax: (412) 369-2236
 

Capitol
Hon. Mike Turzai
139 Main Capitol
PO Box 202028
Harrisburg, PA 17120-2028
(717) 772-9943
Fax: (717) 772-2470

Talking Points: Why defend public education?

Vouchers and charter schools

What they are saying

Public education is a disaster.  Vouchers and charter schools will solve the disaster.

What to say.

Public education can be improved.  Vouchers and charter schools are not the way to do it.  Vouchers will benefit the wealthy.  Vouchers steal money from the coffers that benefit the poor in order to subsidize the wealthy parents who are choosing to send their kids to private schools.  Charter schools aren’t working much better.  There are reports of fraud and discrimination.  Publically funded schools should benefit the public.  Having a centralized source of funding (that’s not based on property tax) would be a good start in improving the educational system disparities.

School Choice

What they are saying

There is no choice in schools.  Charter schools and vouchers will give choice.

What to say.

There is already choice.  You can choose to send your kids to private school, public school, homeschool, online school, and charter schools.  Vouchers only serve those who can afford the difference in tuition for private schools.  

Why should I pay double? Taxes and tuition

What they are saying

Why should I pay for private school tuition and pay into public school education?

What to say

Why should people without children pay into public school education?  It is your choice to send your child to private school.  We pay into the public school education as an investment in our future workforce and economic sustainability.

Why pay taxes into public education?

It is an investment in our future workforce.

Why Public Education is an investment in our country

We need people with progressive values to defend our public schools.  We need to have school board members who see the value and potential for public education.

  1.  What are Trump and his cronies trying to do to education? (1)

Let’s look at the budget.  Trump’s budget cuts $9 BILLION from the Department of Education.  His suggestions for cuts?  Teacher professional development (because who really needs teachers to stay up-to-date on content and technique), after-school programs (because latch-key kids were a great idea), programs in frivolous areas like —  the arts (because music education doesn’t help in math skills — oh wait.  It does), foreign languages (everyone should speak American anyway), history (who needs to learn the past when we can repeat it), and STEM…. because who needs science and technology!  What else?  Special Olympics.  

What does Trump want to do with the budget that’s left?  School vouchers.  This is a great idea.  (NOT).  It steals money from programs for disadvantaged areas and allows people to subsidize their kid’s private education.  Charter Schools.  Although there are some charter schools that are innovative and reach kids who would not get the benefits from a private education, often times they have been found to be fraudulent and discriminatory. Is this how you want your taxes to be invested? What do people like Betsy DeVos have to gain?  That’s a good question.  

DeVos has been quoted saying, “Accordingly, we must shift the paradigm to think about education funding as investments made in individual children, not in institutions or buildings.” (See 5)  That’s nice.  But where exactly are the children supposed to go?  If they can’t afford the difference in tuition for private education or get into a charter school, where are they supposed to go?  

In a nutshell:  

  • Trump and his cronies are preventing access to STEM education, history education, and education in the arts for the people who can’t afford private education.
  • They are stealing tax dollars to subsidize private education.  
  • They are trying to get public funds available for religious charter schools.  
  1.  Public schools produce people of note.  It’s not just private schools that produce the movers, the shakers, and the innovators.  Oprah Winfrey.  Steve Jobs.  Ruth Bader Ginsburg.  They were all educated in public schools.  But public education provides so much more.
  2.  Cutting funding to STEM will decrease our competitiveness in the global economy.  Under the educational system that Trump and his cronies are promoting, STEM education will only be available to their children.  They are crippling the general public in order to feather their own nests.
  3.  History education provides a way for people to understand how society works, cause and effect, and is essential for being an engaged citizen.  If having complacent citizenry is your aim, then by all means — defund history education.  (3)
  4.  Not educating our young is not an option.  These will be the people at your restaurant cooking and serving food.  Having a literate cook or chef is a matter of safety.  Our children are our future workforce.  They will not only be doctors, but also the lady at the coffee shop making your coffee.  In either case, having a literate workforce is essential to a healthy society.  Education is an investment in our work force.

In a nutshell:

  • Education is an investment in our workforce and continued health in our economy.  These are the people who will take care of us when we old, frail, and vulnerable.  

Sources:

  1. https://www.self.com/gallery/public-school
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/29/us/politics/betsy-devos-education-school-choice-voucher.html
  3. https://www.historians.org/about-aha-and-membership/aha-history-and-archives/historical-archives/why-study-history-(1998)